Lawmakers probe if Cuomo’s policy fueled nursing home deaths
Several lawmakers challenged New York’s top health official Thursday over his insistence that a state policy didn’t fuel COVID-19 outbreaks in nursing homes.
Health commissioner Howard Zucker testified for several hours Thursday before a joint legislative committee.
He fielded several questions about the state’s decision in the spring to temporarily bar nursing homes from refusing to accept COVID-19 patients being discharged from hospitals solely because they’d had the virus.
Zucker said he wanted to “move forward” from such questions, but lawmakers, including both Democrats and Republicans, wouldn’t let him.
“It’s troubling to me that we keep going back to an issue where… all the data has shown… that this is not what brought the infection into the nursing homes,” Zucker said.
Most outbreaks were due to infected nursing home staff members unknowingly bringing the virus into facilities, Zucker said. Substantially all nursing homes had at least some infected patients before receiving any recovering COVID-19 patients discharged from hospitals.
Sen. Dan Stec, a Republican, asked Zucker if he’d rather have his grandparent in a room of 20 out of 50 people infected with COVID-19, or a room with one out of 50 infected.
Zucker said he’d be equally concerned in either room: “Because the disease is … already in the facility.”
When asked whether the March directive contributed to outbreaks, Zucker said: “No.”
Zucker added there could have been “that random person” who spread it, but said: “This memo was not the driver of nursing home fatalities.”
Some lawmakers also grilled the commissioner about the state’s underreporting of the number of COVID-19 deaths among residents in nursing homes and assisted living facilities.
The state’s official death toll in long-term care facilities now stands at over 15,000, up from the roughly 9,000 previously disclosed as of late January. Critics say Cuomo was trying to minimize the extent of the pandemic among the state’s most vulnerable at a time when he was lauded for his pandemic leadership.
Lawmakers also questioned why New York ranks among the lowest in the nation for percentage of residents who have received at least one dose of COVID-19 vaccine.
“It is very clear that this administration … will not acknowledge that you have done anything wrong,” Sen. Gustavo Rivera, a Democrat and Senate health committee chair, told Zucker during the hearing. “It’s as though the administration continues every day being perfect and doing nothing wrong.”
A growing body of research does suggest community spread is the biggest risk factor for outbreaks at nursing homes. Zucker has said that if the state didn’t hadn’t encouraged nursing homes to find space for patients being discharged from hospitals, it could have led to catastrophic conditions in emergency departments then overwhelmed with patients.
Long-term care residents represent at least a third of all reported pandemic deaths in New York, roughly in line with the national average, according to data from The COVID Tracking Project and John Hopkins University.
Zucker didn’t answer a lawmaker’s question about whether the governor’s office directed him not to respond for months to lawmakers’ August request for data on people living in nursing homes who died of COVID-19.
Lawmakers also grilled Zucker on legal protections for hospitals and nursing homes, Cuomo’s proposal to slash health spending and the state’s slow vaccine rollout.
Zucker said the administration is “looking” at a state law providing partial immunity to nursing homes and hospitals amid the pandemic. Lawmakers rolled back that immunity last summer, but they left in place provisions that protect certain healthcare providers from being sued or prosecuted over care “related to the diagnosis or treatment of COVID-19.”
State Attorney General Letitia James last month called for New York to eliminate the immunity provisions, particularly for nursing homes that knowingly took on more patients than their staffs could safely handle.
The governor’s budget includes over $1 billion in Medicaid spending cuts on long-term care, and administrators of long-term care homes who weathered 1.5% cuts last year said the state’s nursing homes can’t handle more.
Zucker pointed to a “tight” budget year and said New York’s Medicaid program is spending billions on minimum wage boosts for healthcare employees.